Log in | Register

Norms of decision making in the ICU: a case study of two academic medical centers at the extremes of end-of-life treatment intensity

Amber E. Barnato| Judith A. Tate| Keri L. Rodriguez| Susan L. Zickmund| Robert M. Arnold
Legal and Ethical Issues
Volume 38, Issue 11 / November , 2012

Pages 1886 - 1896

Abstract

Purpose

To explore norms of decision making regarding life-sustaining treatments (LSTs) at two academic medical centers (AMCs) that contribute to their opposite extremes of end-of-life ICU use.

Methods

We conducted a 4-week mixed methods case study at each AMC in 2008–2009 involving direct observation of patient care during rounds in the main medical ICU, semi-structured interviews with staff, patients, and families, and collection of artifacts (e.g., patient lists, standardized forms). We compared patterns of decision making regarding initiation, continuation, and withdrawal of LST using tests of proportions and grounded theory analysis of field note and interview transcripts.

Results

We observed 80 patients [26 (32.5 %) ≥65 years old] staffed by 4 attendings, and interviewed 23 staff and 3 patients/families at the low-intensity AMC (LI-AMC), and observed 73 patients [26 (35.6 %) ≥65 years old] staffed by 4 attending physicians and interviewed 26 staff and 4 patients/families at the high-intensity AMC (HI-AMC). LST initiation among patients over 65 was similar, except feeding tubes (0 % LI-AMC versus 31 % HI-AMC, p = 0.002). The LI-AMC was more likely to use a time-limited trial of LST, followed by withdrawal (27 vs. 8 %, p = 0.01) and to have a known outcome of death (31 vs. 4 %, p < 0.001). We identified qualitative differences in goals of LST, the determination of “dying,” concern about harms of commission versus omission, and physician self-efficacy for LST decision making.

Conclusions

Time-limited trials of LST at the LI-AMC and open-ended use of LST at the HI-AMC explain some of the AMCs’ nationally profiled differences in end-of-life ICU use.

Keywords

References

  1. Wennberg JE, Gittelsohn AM (1973) Small area variations in health care delivery. Science 182:1102–1108
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  2. Wennberg J, Gittelsohn A (1982) Variations in medical care among small areas. Sci Am 246:120–134
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  3. Wennberg JE, Freeman JL, Culp WJ (1987) Are hospital services rationed in New Haven or over-utilised in Boston? Lancet 1:1185–1189
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  4. Chassin MR, Brook RH, Park RE, Keesey J, Fink A, Kosecoff J, Kahn K, Merrick N, Solomon DH (1986) Variations in the use of medical and surgical services by the Medicare population. N Engl J Med 314:285–290
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  5. The Dartmouth atlas of health care in the United States (1999) The quality of medical care in the United States: a report on the Medicare program. AHA, Chicago
  6. Skinner J, Fisher E, Wennberg J (2001) The efficiency of Medicare. In: Skinner J, Fisher E, Wennberg J (eds) The efficiency of Medicare. National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, pp 1–37
  7. Fisher ES, Wennberg DE, Stukel TA, Gottlieb DJ, Lucas FL, Pinder EL (2003) The implications of regional variations in Medicare spending. Part 1: the content, quality, and accessibility of care. Ann Intern Med 138:273–287
    • View reference on PubMed
  8. Fisher ES, Wennberg DE, Stukel TA, Gottlieb DJ, Lucas FL, Pinder EL (2003) The implications of regional variations in Medicare spending. Part 2: health outcomes and satisfaction with care. Ann Intern Med 138:288–298
    • View reference on PubMed
  9. Welch WP, Miller ME, Welch HG, Fisher ES, Wennberg JE (1993) Geographic variation in expenditures for physicians’ services in the United States. N Engl J Med 328:621–627
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  10. Pritchard RS, Fisher ES, Teno JM, Sharp SM, Reding DJ, Knaus WA, Wennberg JE, Lynn J (1998) Influence of patient preferences and local health system characteristics on the place of death. SUPPORT Investigators. Study to understand prognoses and preferences for risks and outcomes of treatment. J Am Geriatr Soc 46:1242–1250
    • View reference on PubMed
  11. Wennberg JE, Freeman JL, Shelton RM, Bubolz TA (1989) Hospital use and mortality among Medicare beneficiaries in Boston and New Haven. N Engl J Med 321:1168–1173
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  12. Fisher ES, Wennberg JE, Stukel TA, Sharp SM (1994) Hospital readmission rates for cohorts of Medicare beneficiaries in Boston and New Haven. N Engl J Med 331:989–995
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  13. Strauss MJ, LoGerfo JP, Yeltatzie JA, Temkin N, Hudson LD (1986) Rationing of intensive care unit services. An everyday occurrence. JAMA 255:1143–1146
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  14. Gatsonis CA, Epstein AM, Newhouse JP, Normand SL, McNeil BJ (1995) Variations in the utilization of coronary angiography for elderly patients with an acute myocardial infarction. An analysis using hierarchical logistic regression. Med Care 33:625–642
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  15. McClellan M (1995) Uncertainty, health-care technologies, and health-care choices. Am Econ Rev 85:38–44
    • View reference on PubMed
  16. Baker LC (1997) The effect of HMOs on fee-for-service health care expenditures: evidence from Medicare. J Health Econ 16:453–481
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  17. Kessler DP, McClellan MC (1999) Is hospital competition socially wasteful? National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge
  18. Taylor DH Jr, Whellan DJ, Sloan FA (1999) Effects of admission to a teaching hospital on the cost and quality of care for Medicare beneficiaries. N Engl J Med 340:293–299
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  19. Vistnes G (1995) Hospital mergers and antitrust enforcement. J Health Polit Policy Law 20:175–190
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  20. Claxton G, Feder J, Schactman D, Altman S (1997) Public policy issues in nonprofit conversions: an overview. Health Aff 16:9–28
    • View reference on publisher's website
  21. Gray BH, McNerney WJ (1986) For-profit enterprise in health care. The Institute of Medicine Study. N Engl J Med 314:1523–1528
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  22. Silverman EM, Skinner JS, Fisher ES (1999) The association between for-profit hospital ownership and increased Medicare spending. N Engl J Med 341:420–426
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  23. Sloan FA, Picone GA, Taylor DH, Chou SY (1998) Hospital ownership and cost and quality of care: is there a dime’s worth of difference? National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge
  24. Lin CY, Farrell MH, Lave JR, Angus DC, Barnato AE (2009) Organizational determinants of hospital end-of-life treatment intensity. Med Care 47:524–530
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  25. Greenfield S, Nelson EC, Zubkoff M, Manning W, Rogers W, Kravitz RL, Keller A, Tarlov AR, Ware JE Jr (1992) Variations in resource utilization among medical specialties and systems of care. Results from the medical outcomes study. JAMA 267:1624–1630
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  26. Selby JV, Grumbach K, Quesenberry CP Jr, Schmittdiel JA, Truman AF (1999) Differences in resource use and costs of primary care in a large HMO according to physician specialty. Health Serv Res 34:503–518
    • View reference on PubMed
  27. Hanson LC, Danis M, Garrett JM, Multran E (1996) Who decides? Physicians’ willingness to use life-sustaining treatment. Arch Intern Med 156:785–789
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  28. McCrary SV, Swanson JW, Perkins HS, Winslade WJ (1992) Treatment decisions for terminally ill patients: physicians’ legal defensiveness and knowledge of medical law. Law Med Health Care 20:364–376
    • View reference on PubMed
  29. Swanson JW, McCrary SV (1996) Medical futility decisions and physicians’ legal defensiveness: the impact of anticipated conflict on thresholds for end-of-life treatment. Soc Sci Med 42:125–132
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  30. McCrary SV, Swanson JW (1999) Physicians’ legal defensiveness and knowledge of medical law: comparing Denmark and the USA. Scand J Public Health 27:18–21
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  31. Pearson SD, Goldman L, Orav EJ, Guadagnoli E, Garcia TB, Johnson PA, Lee TH (1995) Triage decisions for emergency department patients with chest pain: do physicians’ risk attitudes make the difference? J Gen Intern Med 10:557–564
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  32. Allison JJ, Kiefe CI, Cook EF, Gerrity MS, Orav EJ, Centor R (1998) The association of physician attitudes about uncertainty and risk taking with resource use in a Medicare HMO. Med Decis Making 18:320–329
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  33. Franks P, Williams GC, Zwanziger J, Mooney C, Sorbero M (2000) Why do physicians vary so widely in their referral rates? J Gen Intern Med 15:163–168
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  34. Abelson R (2009) Weighing medical costs of end-of-life care. The New York Times Company, New York
  35. Gawande A (2009) The cost conundrum: what a Texas town can teach us about health care. Conde Nast, London
  36. Bertolini G, Boffelli S, Malacarne P, Peta M, Marchesi M, Barbisan C, Tomelleri S, Spada S, Satolli R, Gridelli B, Lizzola I, Mazzon D (2010) End-of-life decision-making and quality of ICU performance: an observational study in 84 Italian units. Intensive Care Med 36:1495–1504
  37. Cook D, Rocker G, Marshall J, Sjokvist P, Dodek P, Griffith L, Freitag A, Varon J, Bradley C, Levy M, Finfer S, Hamielec C, McMullin J, Weaver B, Walter S, Guyatt G (2003) Withdrawal of mechanical ventilation in anticipation of death in the intensive care unit. N Engl J Med 349:1123–1132
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  38. Prendergast TJ, Claessens MT, Luce JM (1998) A national survey of end-of-life care for critically ill patients. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 158:1163–1167
    • View reference on PubMed
  39. Cook DJ, Guyatt GH, Jaeschke R, Reeve J, Spanier A, King D, Molloy DW, Willan A, Streiner DL (1995) Determinants in Canadian health care workers of the decision to withdraw life support from the critically ill. Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. JAMA 273:703–708
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  40. Sprung CL, Cohen SL, Sjokvist P, Baras M, Bulow HH, Hovilehto S, Ledoux D, Lippert A, Maia P, Phelan D, Schobersberger W, Wennberg E, Woodcock T (2003) End-of-life practices in European intensive care units: the Ethicus Study. JAMA 290:790–797
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  41. Wennberg JE, Fisher ES, Goodman DC, Skinner JS (eds) (2008) Tracking the care of patients with severe chronic illness: the Dartmouth atlas of health care. The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice, Hanover
  42. Patton MQ (2001) Qualitative research and evaluation methods. Sage, Newbury Park
  43. Lunney JR, Lynn J, Hogan C (2002) Profiles of older Medicare decedents. J Am Geriatr Soc 50:1108–1112
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  44. Lunney JR, Lynn J, Foley DJ, Lipson S, Guralnik JM (2003) Patterns of functional decline at the end of life. J Am Med Assoc 289:2387–2392
    • View reference on publisher's website
  45. Miller WL, Crabtree BF (1992) Primary care research: a multi-typology and qualitative road map. In: Crabtree BF, Miller WL (eds) Doing qualitative research. Sage, London
  46. Landis JR, Koch GG (1977) The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics 33:159–174
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  47. Lilly CM, De Meo DL, Sonna LA, Haley KJ, Massaro AF, Wallace RF, Cody S (2000) An intensive communication intervention for the critically ill. Am J Med 109:469–475
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  48. Curtis JR, White DB (2008) Practical guidance for evidence-based ICU family conferences. Chest 134:835–843
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website
  49. Morden NE, Chang CH, Jacobson JO, Berke EM, Bynum JP, Murray KM, Goodman DC (2012) End-of-life care for Medicare beneficiaries with cancer is highly intensive overall and varies widely. Health Aff (Millwood) 31:786–796
    • View reference on publisher's website
  50. Azoulay E, Metnitz B, Sprung CL, Timsit JF, Lemaire F, Bauer P, Schlemmer B, Moreno R, Metnitz P (2009) End-of-life practices in 282 intensive care units: data from the SAPS 3 database. Intensive Care Med 35:623–630
  51. Zussman R (1992) Intensive care: medical ethics and the medical profession. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
  52. Cassell J (2005) Life and death in intensive care. Temple University Press, Philadelphia
  53. Cassell J, Buchman TG, Streat S, Stewart RM (2003) Surgeons, intensivists, and the covenant of care: administrative models and values affecting care at the end of life–updated. Crit Care Med 31:1551–1557 (discussion 1557–1559)
    • View reference on PubMed
    • View reference on publisher's website

Sign In

Connect with ICM

Top 5 Articles Editors Picks Supplement